Appointments+ charging Memberships group even though I have it set to not charge a deposit for that

So I have purchased both the Appointments+ plugin and the Memberships plugin for my barbershop web site. I've installed both and have most functions working properly however I'm running into issues with the integration.

In the administration panel for Appointments+ I have payments required along with a $5 flat fee for appointments. I have the option Don't ask advance payment from selected Membership level(s) checked as well for my VIP member level. I've double checked and my user level matches up with the access but when I go to book the appointment it continues to require me to pay the $5 deposit prior to confirming my appointment. It's as if the integration isn't working at all.

I've even tried to just give a 100% discount instead of just checking the payment not required option and I'm still being charged.